Thursday, 6 May 2010

Music. My Edit

Music is important in all film. For my documentary I want the music to help convey a mood at a particular moment. There are parts of my edit that are optimistic, inquisitive, pessimistic, jovial and sombre.

Here is the music I have selected for each part of the edit.

Optimistic:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQtfntyVTNU

This song sounds quite upbeat and optimistic. This juxtaposes the negativity conveyed in the film which helps to match the module title I produced the documentary for entitled "Making Trouble for the Public Good".

Inquisitive:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nFhJGwjfDBk

This song will help the feeling of trying to find out something. I feel that when the beat kicks in I will be able to time the visuals to match this, before delving into the public voice-box. The music will cut once the man with strong opinions starts talking as he is important to the narrative and I want to keep the tone of the documentary serious.

Pessimistic:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_rl1qbz5_nI&feature=related

This song is very depressing and melodramatic and follows on from an interview from someone who was fairly negative about the chances of Media Students breaking into the industry. I feel it will match the rainy drab shot of the Sheffield wheel and show a sign of things to come, when we interview the rather disheartening character of Hussain.

Jovial:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e-2H4-OGmpE

This songs bass line is quite jovial and melodic. I feel this will match the character being interviewed in the film quite well as I found him to be light hearted and laid back. I feel this shows elements of positivity which is important for this particular sequence.

Sombre:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vslbQNkFLl8

The songs mood is quite sombre, which helps to create feelings of rest and reassurance but not entirely positive. I feel this will be quite important to the concluding montage and help the documentary go out with a bit of a bang.


Influence. My edit.

I have been watching the films of Andrei Tarkovsky, I really enjoyed the film 'Ivans Childhood'.

I particularly enjoyed the opening, it conveys a very positive mood. I wish to convey positive feelings in my own work. I felt the music played a big part, it also used visually stunning shots.

In the article (link posted below), the writer talks about the rejection of montage in the work of Tarkovsky.

I intend to use montage but I still found Tarkovsky to be quite an interesting film maker.

Reading the article I have established that Tarkovsky tends to use long sequences, repeating shots to show the character trying to achieve his goals but without using a 3minute montage to glue together the 'struggle' of the character and how he/she eventually solves his/ her problems.

Instead Tarkovsky chooses to show the clip over and over again until the character solved the problem, even if this means playing the same clip over a 15 minute duration.

Unfortunately because of my time restrictions I will have to make use of montage but I agree in a sense that montage isn't truthful because it covers a vast array of information in a short time scale, wheras a struggle could take a long period of time.

An interesting quote on Tarkovskys distaste for montage from the man himself.

"The idea of "montage cinema"—that editing brings together two concepts and thus engenders a new, third one—again seems to me to be incompatible with the nature of cinema. Art can never have the interplay of concepts as its ultimate goal. The image is tied to the concrete and the material, yet reaches out along mysterious paths to regions beyond the spirit..."

http://www.ce-review.org/00/39/kinoeye39_halligan.html


Degrees of Seperation. My edit.

I have been reading a magazine article about engagement of the audience entitled, 'point of view'. The bit that interested me was the discussion of 'subjectivity' . We have shots of Mark Herbert talking almost directly at camera.

I think after reading the article it is clear that when the subject looks directly at camera it seems more personal.

I intend to use this for effect in my film. In my opening montage I will have some of the characters talk to the camera. Coupled with his dialogue, the shots of Hussain will aim to shock the audience in order to keep them interested for the rest of the doc.


Here Hussain looks directly at camera and says "Its crap, its going to be crap, youre just going to die crap". This was taken out of context for the purposes of shocking the viewer and served as a memorable quote which inspired the title of the documentary.



To have an acclaimed producer speaking almost directly to camera helps to show a more personal point of view. Mark is extremely informative in his answer and I feel this is best as my documentary serves to educate as well as entertain.

Presentation tomorrow

Having completed my edit and presented it today, it received a good response, similar to the one I believe Jonathan to have had with his cut. Steve didn't have any criticism really, other than that it seemed to suggest an underlying message that money is important for us media students, and that this 'success' is what we're looking for. I disagree of course, but can see where he is coming from, in my edit anyway.

It seems like we have got two very strong cuts to go with tomorrow, and today is the day we decide which one we choose. Either way I am very pleased with our progress on this film.

Editing improved.

Yesterday I received some useful suggestions from Jonathan to improve my edit. The majority of the improvements were made to the sound.

The first general improvement I made was using the pen tool to make the sound fade in and out to a more professional standard, rather than using the cross fade effect.

The screenshot shows how, especially with the voiceover sections, I faded the sound in and out with the pen tool to clear it up and give it a more professional standard. I also dipped the audio levels of the sound track where necessary, to give more emphasis on the voiceover. As Jonathan also pointed out, some of the audio levels were peaking into red and so I had to alter these slightly which meant adjusting some of the other levels also. Quite a few of his other suggestions on the audio were also to move some of the songs to start a bit earlier. I feel this has worked really well in parts where it overlaps the end of the interview, and the beginning of the next voiceover.

He had suggested to use some cutaways at certain parts of the film. Below shows one attempt at doing so.


However, I felt that the use of cutaways in this part felt lost because they weren't really relevant to what Hussain the interviewee was saying, and the only one I could find that remotely seemed relevant just seemed pointless on its own. Furthermore, I wanted to keep a Cinema Verite feel to the interviews, and this was the same with the Tom Gatis interview. Not only that but in terms of his suggestion with cutting parts out, although I did want to also, I felt that with all the information being given by the interview itself, it was too important to cut any out. In the end I decided to remove the cutaway attempt, and rather than go back to using a cross dissolve effect like before hand, I didn't insert anything and left it how it was. I was pleased with the end result and felt it is somewhat of a compromise. I haven't changed any other parts in the interview as I felt they worked better.

However I did have some slight problems with the soundtrack of 'Air France - No excuses' because when I tried to use the pen tool, it would insist on cutting the beginning of the song out, which was the section of the song I wanted.

This screenshot shows how I ended up keeping the cross fade at the beginning of the song because it had the correct result I was wanting.

Wednesday, 5 May 2010

Final Meeting

Meet at 11:30 at the downstairs cafe tomorrow. Harry suggested planning the presentation for Friday, so we'll definitely spend an hour or so on this. I also want everybody to have a last look through the group folder and see if I have missed anything.

See you then!

Monday, 3 May 2010

Group Folder - Research Materials

If anybody has any research materials, even a few notes on anything you've seen that might have influenced the documentary at all, could I have them for the group folder please?

Also Dan/Jonathan, if you have any notes on editing styles/influences I will need these too.

I'll need everything for the group folder by Wednesday at the latest! Thanks